It happened around 9 p.m. Saturday at the Fraternal Order of Eagles on 2nd Street at Columbus Avenue, according to the Grand Haven Department of Public Safety.
Police said the men took a large Santa decoration on a dolly.
They were driving a silver full-size GMC Sierra. Anyone with information about the thieves is asked to call police at 616.842.3460 orSilent Observerat 877.887.4536.